For other places with this name, see Elma. {{#invoke:Coordinates|coord}}{{#coordinates:42|49|17|N|78|38|13|W|type:city_region:US-NY |primary |name= }} Elma Town Country United States State New York County Erie County Elevation 869 ft (264.9 m) Coordinates coord}}{{#coordinates: 42|49|17|N|78|38|13|W|type:city_region:US-NY name= }} Area 34.5 sq mi (89.4 km) - land 34.5 sq mi (89 km) - water 0.0 sq mi (0 km), 0% Population 11,317 Incorporated 1857 Town Supervisor Dennis Powers Town Council Michael Nolan James Malczewski Tracy W. Petrocy Thomas M. Fallon Timezone EST - summer (DST) EDT ZIP code 14059 Area code 716 FIPS code 36-24130 GNIS feature ID 0978937